How To Do Payroll By Yourself: Complete Guide for Small Businesses (2024)

Expertly handle payroll independently with our guide. From employee classifications to tax obligations, gain the knowledge needed to streamline operations while maintaining compliance.

Payroll Management

Note: Run a Canadian business? You’ll want to check out our guide here instead.

Are you a small business owner looking to take control of your payroll process?

Managing payroll can seem daunting, but with the right knowledge and tools, you can streamline your operations and ensure accuracy and compliance.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about how to do payroll by yourself. From understanding employee classifications to choosing your own payroll service provider and software and navigating tax responsibilities, we've got you covered.

So, let's dive in!

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding payroll basics and its importance as a small business owner
  • 3 step guide to DIY payroll processing
  • Understanding payroll tax responsibility as business owners
  • A guide to help you choose the right payroll software
  • 5 common payroll mistakes people make and how you can avoid them

What is Payroll and Why is it Important?

Payroll calculates and distributes employee compensation by the employee's gross pay, including the employee's gross pay for wages, salaries, bonuses, and withholdings.

In addition to ensuring employees are paid accurately and on time, payroll involves complying with legal and regulatory requirements related to tax withholding, reporting, and record keeping.

Effective payroll management is essential for maintaining employee morale and wages, promoting financial stability, and demonstrating compliance with labor laws and regulations.

Importance of Payroll

Payroll is critical in small business operations by ensuring employees are compensated fairly and timely, fostering employee satisfaction and retention, and promoting financial accountability and compliance.

In fact, accurate and efficient payroll management helps businesses attract and retain top talent, minimize legal risks, and build a positive reputation as an employer.

By prioritizing payroll, small businesses can improve their overall operational efficiency, financial health, and long-term sustainability.

Mastering Small Business Payroll Basics: A Step-by-Step Guide

Here's a 3 step guide to acing payroll records as a small business owner. For your convenience, we've divided each section into subcategories.

Step 1: Employee Classification

The first thing you need to do is correctly classify your employee records.

Here are a few important reasons why employee classification is necessary:

  • It helps ensure compliance with labor laws such as the Fair Labor Standards Act(FLSA). It provides specific rights and protections for different types of employees, including minimum wage requirements, overtime pay eligibility, and employee benefits entitlement.
  • Employee classification affects tax obligations for both employers and employees. For example, full-time employees may be eligible for employer-sponsored benefits such as health insurance and retirement plans. At the same time, independent contractors are responsible for paying their taxes and benefits. Accurate classification ensures correct taxes are withheld and reported to tax authorities.
  • It decreases your liability and legal risks. For example, misclassified employees may file complaints or lawsuits alleging violations of labor laws, such as unpaid wages or benefits. Additionally, government agencies may conduct audits or investigations into employee classification practices, resulting in fines or penalties for non-compliance.

Difference Between Full-Time, Part-Time, and Contract Employees

Understanding the distinctions between full-time, part-time, and contract employees is critical for payroll management and compliance with labor laws and tax regulations.

So, here's a quick breakdown of the different types of employees:

1. Full-Time Employees

Full-time employees typically work a standard number of hours per week as defined by the employer, often 40 hours or more. They are entitled to health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off (e.g., vacation, sick leave), and other perks the employer offers.

Full-time employees may be classified as exempt or non-exempt from overtime pay requirements under the FLSA, depending on their job duties and salary level.

2. Part-Time Employees

Part-time employees work fewer hours than full-time employees, often on a schedule determined by the employer. Depending on company policies and applicable laws, they may be eligible for some benefits. Still, benefits packages are typically prorated based on the employee's net pay and number of hours worked.

Part-time employees are generally entitled to overtime pay under the FLSA if they work overtime hours or more than 40 hours in a workweek unless specific state laws or industry exemptions exempt overtime hours.

3. Contract Employees or Independent Contractors

Contract employees, also known as independent contractors, are self-employed individuals hire employees who provide services to a business under a contract or agreement.

They typically have more control over their work schedule and methods than traditional employees and may work for multiple clients or companies simultaneously.

Contract employees are responsible for paying their taxes, including self-employment taxes, and are not eligible for employee benefits provided by the hiring company.

Step 2: Gathering Necessary Information

Next, gathering accurate and up-to-date information from your employees is essential. This includes personal and tax-related information, which ensures compliance with tax laws, federal and state taxes, and regulations.

Here's why gathering the correct employee tax and personal information is important for payroll:

  • It's necessary for calculating and withholding the correct amount of federal, state, and local taxes from their paychecks. Employers are required by law to withhold taxes from employee wages and remit them to the appropriate tax authorities on behalf of their employees.
  • Employers must report employee wages and tax withholdings to government agencies, such as the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and state revenue departments. Accurate employee information is essential for preparing and filing required tax forms, such as Form W-2 (Wage and Tax Statement) and Form 941 (Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return).
  • In addition to tax-related information, employers may also need personal details from employees to administer employee benefits programs, such as health insurance, retirement plans, and other fringe benefits. This information helps ensure that employees receive the benefits they are entitled to under company policies and applicable laws.

Explanation of the W-4 Form and its Importance

The W-4 form, officially known as the Employee's Withholding Certificate, is crucial for gathering employee tax-related information.

Here's why the W-4 form is important:

  • The W-4 form helps determine the correct amount of federal income tax to withhold from each employee's paycheck based on their filing status, withholding allowances, and any additional withholding requests. Employees must accurately complete the W-4 form to ensure that the correct amount of taxes is withheld from their wages.
  • They help update tax information. Employees must submit a new W-4 form to their employer whenever their tax or personal situation changes, such as getting married, having a child, or starting a second job. Updating the W-4 form ensures that tax withholdings accurately reflect changes in an employee's tax status and helps prevent under or over-withholding of taxes.
  • Employers must comply with IRS guidelines for administering the W-4 form and withholding taxes from employee wages. Failure to accurately withhold taxes based on the information provided on the W-4 form can result in penalties and legal liabilities for the employer.

Step 3: Setting Up Payroll Schedule

Choosing the right payroll schedule is crucial for managing cash flow, meeting financial obligations, and ensuring timely employee payment. There are several types of payroll schedules to consider, each with its advantages and considerations.

Here are the 4 main types of payroll processing schedules:

1. Weekly Payroll

With a weekly payroll schedule, employees are paid weekly, typically every Friday or the last working day of the pay period during the week. This frequent pay frequency gives employees more regular income and can help with budgeting and cash flow management.

However, it may also increase administrative workload and processing costs for employers processing payroll itself.

2. Bi-Weekly Payroll

Bi-weekly payroll schedules involve paying employees every two weeks, typically on the same day of the week, such as every other Friday.

Bi-weekly pay periods result in 26 pay periods per year, making calculating annual salary and benefits contributions easier. This schedule is common among businesses and balances frequent pay and reduced administrative burden.

3. Semi-Monthly Payroll

Semi-monthly payroll schedules involve paying employees twice a month, typically on the 15th and last day of the month or another predetermined schedule. This per gross pay schedule results in 24 pay periods per year, and each pay period may align with monthly billing cycles and financial reporting periods.

However, it may require more careful employee budgeting due to varying pay dates.

4. Monthly Payroll

Monthly payroll schedules involve paying employees once a month, typically on the same day each month, such as the first or last working day. Monthly pay periods simplify manual payroll processing and reduce administrative overhead for employers.

However, employees may struggle to budget and manage expenses with less frequent pay.

Choosing the Best Payroll Schedule for Your Business

When selecting a payroll schedule for your business, consider the following factors to determine the best fit:

1. Employee Preferences

Consider your employees' preferences and financial needs when choosing a payroll schedule. Some employees prefer more frequent pay periods to help with budgeting and managing expenses, while others prefer less frequent pay periods for simplicity and consistency.

2. Budgetary Constraints

Consider your business's cash flow and budgetary constraints when choosing a payroll schedule. More frequent pay periods may increase administrative costs and processing fees, while less frequent pay periods may help conserve cash flow and reduce administrative overhead.

3. Administrative Workload

Evaluate the administrative workload associated with different payroll schedules, including time spent processing payroll, calculating taxes, and preparing reports.

Choose a payroll schedule that balances meeting employee needs and minimizing administrative burdens for your business owners.

4. Tax Withholding and Reporting

Be aware of the tax implications of different payroll schedules, including tax withholding and reporting requirements.

Some pay frequencies may require frequent tax withholdings and filings, while others may offer more tax planning and compliance flexibility.

Understanding Your Payroll Tax Responsibilities

Federal Payroll Taxes

Federal payroll taxes are a significant aspect of small business payroll management, including federal income tax, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax.

Employers are responsible for withholding these federal taxes due from employee paychecks and remitting them to the appropriate federal government and agencies.

Understanding each tax's calculation methods and filing requirements is essential for compliance process payroll deductions and avoiding penalties.

State and Local Payroll Taxes

In addition to federal taxes, many states and local jurisdictions impose payroll taxes on employers. These taxes may include state and federal income taxes and tax, federal unemployment tax and insurance, and local occupational taxes gross wages.

The specific requirements vary depending on your location, so be sure to research the tax obligations that apply to your business and stay up-to-date on any changes to tax laws or regulations.

How to Choose the Right Payroll Software for Your Small Business

There is a lot of payroll software available online. But not every other payroll service provider software will match your business needs.

So here is our expert advice to help you choose the right payroll software for your business.

1. Assess Your Business Needs

Before diving into the sea of payroll software options, take some time to assess your business's unique needs and requirements.

Consider factors such as the size of your workforce, budget constraints, the complexity of your payroll processes, and any specific features or functionalities you require.

By understanding your business needs upfront, you can narrow your options and focus on software solutions that best fit your organization.

2. Look at Scalability and Flexibility

As your business grows and evolves, so too will your payroll needs. Look for payroll software that offers scalability and flexibility to accommodate your changing requirements over time.

Consider whether the software can easily adapt to accommodate additional employees, changes in pay structure, or new compliance requirements. A scalable solution will grow with your business, saving you the hassle of switching to a new system.

3. Choose a User-Friendly Interface

Ease of use is essential for payroll software, especially for small business owners who may not have a background in accounting or HR. Look for software with an intuitive, user-friendly interface that makes it easy to navigate and perform tasks such as processing payroll, generating reports, and managing employee data.

A visually appealing and logically organized interface can save you time, cut down onboarding time and frustration, allowing you to focus on running your business rather than wrestling with complex software.

4. Integration Capabilities

Payroll is just one piece of the puzzle regarding managing your business's finances and HR processes. Look for payroll software that seamlessly integrates with other key systems and applications you use, such as accounting software, time-tracking tools, and HR management platforms.

Integration capabilities can streamline data sharing and eliminate the need for manual data entry, saving you time and reducing the risk of errors. Check whether the software offers pre-built integrations with popular business tools or supports custom integrations.

5. Check the Compliance and Security Features

Compliance with tax laws, labor regulations, and data privacy requirements is critical for small businesses.

Look for payroll software with robust compliance and security features to help you stay on the right side of the law and protect sensitive employee data.

This may include features such as automatic tax updates to reflect changes in tax rates or withholding tables, built-in compliance checks to flag potential errors or discrepancies, and advanced security measures such as encryption and multi-factor authentication to safeguard against data breaches.

6. Customer Support and Training Resources

Even the best software can be challenging to navigate, so it's essential to consider the level of customer support and training resources the software vendor provides.

Look for a payroll software provider that offers responsive customer support via phone, email, or live chat and comprehensive online documentation, video tutorials, and training webinars to help you get up to speed quickly.

5 Common Payroll Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Here are five common payroll mistakes and strategies to avoid them:

1. Misclassification of Employees:

Misclassifying employees as independent contractors can lead to legal and financial consequences, including penalties for unpaid taxes and benefits.

To avoid this, you must understand the criteria used to differentiate between employees and independent contractors according to IRS guidelines.

Conduct regular audits of worker classifications to ensure compliance with local, federal, and state regulations, taxes, and labor laws. Seek legal advice if unsure about a worker's classification.

2. Incorrect Tax Withholdings:

Calculating incorrect tax withholdings can result in underpayment of federal unemployment tax or overpayment of taxes, leading to financial discrepancies post-tax deductions and potential penalties.

We'd advise using accurate and up-to-date tax tables and formulas the IRS or payroll software provides.

Verify employee information on Form W-4, including filing status and allowances, to file tax forms to ensure accurate withholding calculations. Regularly review and update tax withholdings as employee circumstances change.

3. Late Payroll Tax Payments:

Missing deadlines for payroll deductions, tax deposits, or filings can result in penalties, interest charges, and negative implications for cash flow management.

Familiarize yourself with tax deposit schedules, tax deductions, and filing deadlines for federal, state, and local payroll taxes.

Set up reminders or automated alerts to ensure timely submission of tax payments and reports. You can also utilize electronic filing and payment options to expedite the process and minimize the risk of delays.

4. Incomplete Record keeping:

Poor record keeping practices, such as failing to maintain accurate payroll records or not retaining required documentation, can result in compliance issues and audit challenges.

Establish standardized record keeping procedures for payroll data, including employee information, wage records, tax filings, and benefits documentation. Maintain organized payroll records in electronic or physical files for easy retrieval and review.

5. Ignoring Compliance Requirements:

Neglecting to comply with federal, state, and local labor laws and regulations can lead to legal liabilities, fines, and damage to the reputation of your business.

Stay informed about changes to labor laws, state income tax and regulations, and reporting requirements that may impact payroll administration.

Invest in ongoing HR and payroll staff training to ensure awareness of compliance obligations and best practices. Consult with legal or tax professionals when in doubt about compliance issues.

6 DIY Payroll Tips: Making Payroll Management Easier

Investing time and effort into optimizing your own payroll and processes will increase efficiency, reduce risks, and improve employee satisfaction.

So, here are 6 DIY payroll tips to make payroll management easier for small businesses:

1. Utilize Payroll Software or Online Services

Take advantage of payroll software or online payroll services tailored for small businesses. These tools streamline payroll processing by automating calculations, tax withholdings, and even direct deposit deposits.

Choose a solution that fits your budget and offers features such as employee self-service portals and tax filing assistance.

2. Set Up a Dedicated Payroll Bank Account

Maintain a separate bank account specifically for payroll transactions. This helps you track direct deposit and pay payroll taxes and expenses more efficiently and simplifies reconciliation.

Use this business bank account exclusively for depositing payroll funds and paying employee wages and taxes to avoid commingling funds for payroll manually with other business expenses.

3. Establish a Consistent Payroll Schedule

Set a regular payroll schedule to keep income taxes and ensure timely and predictable employee payments.

Whether you pay employees weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly, stick to a consistent pay period manual payroll schedule to maintain employee satisfaction and compliance with labor laws. Communicate the payroll schedule to employees and adhere to the income tax deposit and filing deadlines.

4. Stay Organized with Payroll Records

Maintain well-organized payroll and data records, including employee information, time and attendance records, pay stubs, and tax filings.

Use payroll software or cloud-based storage solutions to centralize and secure payroll documents for easy access and retrieval. Regularly review and update payroll records to ensure accuracy and compliance with record keeping requirements.

5. Stay Informed About Tax Laws and Regulations:

Stay on top of changes to federal, state, and local tax laws and regulations that may impact payroll processing.

Subscribe to newsletters or updates from tax authorities such as the IRS or state revenue departments to receive timely information about tax rate changes, various tax filing deadlines, and compliance requirements.

6. Conduct Regular Payroll Audits:

Conduct periodic audits of your payroll processes to proactively identify and correct errors or discrepancies.

Review employee records, wage calculations, tax withholdings, and benefit deductions to ensure accuracy and compliance with legal requirements. Address any issues promptly and implement corrective measures to prevent recurrence in the future.


We hope that this guide helped you understand how to do payroll by yourself. Following the steps outlined in this article, you can handle payroll confidently and ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

But remember, payroll management is an ongoing process that requires attention to detail, ongoing education, and a commitment to excellence. Whether you handle payroll in-house or outsource to a professional provider, prioritize accuracy, efficiency, and compliance to support your business's success.

Ready to take your payroll to the next level?

Explore KnitPeople for an all-in-one payroll solution tailored to all sizes of businesses.