Back

Do Companies Have to Pay Out PTO? (Guide for 2024)

Learn about Paid Time Off (PTO) policies and how they differ from state to state. Navigate different PTO scenarios and situations with our guide.

Hiring and Growth

Paid Time Off (PTO) is an important benefit that allows employees to take time away from work for vacation, personal days, sick leave, and other reasons while still being paid. PTO policies vary widely between companies and are governed by different state laws and regulations

In this comprehensive guide, we'll explain everything you need to know about PTO regulations, from understanding state laws to the types of payout PTO has, and address your concerns regarding the PTO payout laws.

Let’s start!

Key Takeaways

  • Learn about the Paid Time Off - PTO payout laws and their importance for employees and employers.
  • Explore the 7 different types of PTO leaves and vacation pay. 
  • Discover the 5 benefits of Paid Time Off and vacation pay.
  • Get a comprehensive guide on navigating the PTO payout laws by state and what states require PTO payout laws.
  • Get insights into the unique cases of North Carolina and Rhode Island to pay employees.
  • Compare company policies vs state laws addressing different regulations about vacation pay.
  • Learn to navigate different scenarios and situations, such as payout upon termination. 

What is Paid Time Off?

Paid Time Off (PTO) is a company and state-approved paid time off from work that can be used as vacation pay or for any other personal reason.

It is like a free pass for employees to take some time off work without fear of losing their paycheck.

It's one of the benefits provided to employees, who are paid for hours or days off, depending on their employment contract.

How does PTO Work?

HR professionals usually outline employees' PTO in their contracts, including all days employees can take off, such as statutory holidays each year, when they are ill, and other personal days. Some companies accrue hours over time, providing employees with the flexibility to save them for a perfect getaway.

Conversely, others offer a set amount annually that is ideal for planning vacations or taking sick leaves. 

The best part?

PTO is all about paid time off, which means employees won't have to worry about paychecks while taking a day off to enjoy themselves on the beaches, at home, watching their favorite TV shows, or reading a good book.

Types of Paid Time Off

There are several different types of paid time off. Let's discuss the most important ones.

1. Vacation Time

Everyone needs a break to be productive and avoid burnout from work.

Employees also deserve the chance to take a respite, whether discovering their city's hidden gems or unwinding in a peaceful countryside cottage. Vacation time can be your rescue! 

Vacations are a chance to refresh your mind, rejuvenate your soul, and experience cherishing moments with loved ones. Taking much-needed time off can reduce stress, elevate mood, and foster relationships with friends and family.

2. Sick Time

We all dread getting sick! 

But, when illness strikes, take some time off to care for your health and recover without the stress of deadlines looming over your head. 

Whether you’re battling a frustrating stomachache or feeling a cold coming on, sick leave is often available to ensure that workers can take some rest when they do not feel their best.

Sick days are typically counted separately from vacation time.

3. Personal Days

Life is unpredictable! You never know what might be waiting around the corner. And this is where personal days off can be your savior. 

Workers can utilize this special time away from their jobs for personal reasons. Want to tackle that never-ending to-do list finally? Or is your cousin’s wedding coming up this week?

You can use this leave to relax, switch off your thoughts, and concentrate on yourself. Similarly, many employees use these days as mental health days.

4. Bereavement Leave

Losing a loved one is an extremely emotional and personal experience.

Employees are often allotted bereavement days to grieve and deal with the emotional turmoil of an unexpected loss. Use this time to manage planning, attend funerals, and process everything without worrying about work.

5. Paid Holidays

Everyone loves a good holiday time, free from the stress of work and getting things done.

Are you Celebrating Christmas or planning a grand Thanksgiving Dinner? Regardless of the occasion, these statutory holidays allow us to take some time off work, indulge in the festive season, and celebrate with our friends and family.

6. Floating Holidays

Not as common as traditional holidays, floating holidays are your ticket to epic adventures but are often “use it or lose it.” They allow your team to take time off whenever needed, whether for cultural festivals, religious events, or simply a day to rest and look after their mental well-being.

It's all about personal choice and well-being!

7. Parental Leave

A new addition to the family is an important event that no one wants to miss! The good news is that parental leave allows new parents to spend precious time with their children in those essential early weeks and months. 

On the Federal Level:

  • The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for eligible employees at covered employers (public agencies, schools, and companies with 50+ employees
  • In 2020, the Federal Employee Paid Leave Act began providing 12 weeks of paid parental leave to most federal employees.
  • There is currently no federal law mandating paid parental leave for private sector employees.

State level:

  • 13 states and D.C. have enacted paid family and medical leave laws that include parental leave, with varying degrees of comprehensiveness
  • 8 states have voluntary paid family leave systems through private insurance markets

Image Credit: bipartisanpolicy.org

Benefits of PTO Policies

A paid time off policy is a combination of an employee's paid time off, including vacation time, sick leave, bereavement leave, and more. These can effectively produce flexibility and control for their employees.  

PTO policies offer numerous benefits to the clients, including: 

1. Simple Tracking

No need to complicate things with PTO! 

PTO policies group all types of leaves into one single PTO bank. This can effectively simplify the administration of time off for the employer and the employees. These policies are a simple process that doesn’t require HR professionals to track the different PTO durations individually. 

2. Offers Flexibility

As an employee, imagine being able to take a day off whenever you want, whether it be sick, for personal appointments, or to attend a friend's wedding. Your employment contract already outlines the PTO as one of the benefits.

PTO policies empower employees with the flexibility to balance their personal and work lives effectively.

3. Accrual

PTO policies often allow leave to accrue over time. This enables employees to build up PTO hours over time, which is extremely beneficial for both employer and employee. It encourages them to continue working longer and provides more time if needed.  

4. Helps with Compliance

With so many state rules and regulations, it can be easy for employers to get it wrong when it comes to compliance with PTO. Hiring experts in administering PTO policies can ensure compliance with state and federal laws and regulations.

Companies must establish clear PTO policies and specify leave types to mitigate the risks of landing in legal hot waters. 

5. Promotes Employees Well-being

Having multiple types of time off will help put your employees at ease and show that you are taking care of their well-being from day one.

Besides, you would think all of your employees would jump at the chance to use up their Health and Dental insurance, but some research has suggested that the wellness program category only has an average usage rate of 40%!

Imagine that. Employers have a hard time even getting them to take their massage therapy.

Navigating PTO Payout Laws by State

Paid time off payout laws in the United States can significantly vary from one state to another. However, understanding these laws can facilitate fair treatment and compliance with regulations for employers and employees. 

Here’s a comprehensive breakdown by state for PTO and payout laws.

State Use-it-or-lose-it Policy Statutory Requirements Addressing Vacation Pay Requirement of PTO Payout at Termination
Alabama No No No
Alaska No, but you do have an earned right to vacation pay. No No
Arizona No No No
Arkansas No Only for state employees. No
California Yes. However, employees can implement an accrual cap on vacation time. Yes Yes
Colorado No. But, it is only permitted if the policy is already included in a written agreement i.e. employee contract or employee handbook. Yes Yes
Connecticut No No No
Delaware No No No
District of Columbia No Yes No
Florida No No No
Georgia No No No
Hawaii No No No
Idaho No No No
Illinois The State’s law permits it. However, employees must be educated on this policy. Moreover, the employees must have a fair opportunity to use this vacation time. But, the employers get the final say in allowing the carry-over of the yearly, unused vacation period. Yes Yes
Indiana The state law hasn't addressed it. But, it's permitted by Indiana courts. Yes Yes
Iowa No No No
Kansas No. It's permitted by state law. No No
Kentucky No No No
Louisiana No. It's permitted by state law. No Yes
Maine No. It's permitted by state law. Yes Yes
Maryland No Yes No
Massachusetts No. While permitted by State law, employees are required to provide employees with a fair notice of the policy. Yes Yes
Michigan No No No
Minnesota No Yes No
Mississippi No No No
Missouri No No No
Montana Yes. However, employees can implement the accrual cap on vacation time. Yes Yes
Nebraska Yes Yes Yes
Nevada No No No
New Hampshire No. It's permitted by state law. No No
New Jersey No No No
New Mexico No Yes No
New York No. While permitted by State law, employees must provide advance notice of the policy. Yes No
North Carolina No. Permitted by the State law. Employees are required to share notices in writing of any time off policies that can potentially result in the loss of vacation time. Yes No
North Dakota No. Permitted by State law. Employees are required to provide fair notice of the policy. Yes No
Ohio No Yes No
Oklahoma No. It's permitted by state law. No No
Oregon No No No
Pennsylvania No No No
Rhode Island No Yes Yes
South Carolina No No No
South Dakota No No No
Tennessee No No No
Texas No No No
Utah No No No
Vermont No No No
Virginia No No No
Washington No No No
West Virginia No Yes No
Wisconsin No No No
Wyoming No Yes No

 

States with Mandatory PTO Payout Requirements

  • California
  • Colorado
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Louisiana
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Minnesota
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Rhode Island
  • West Virginia
  • Wyoming

The Unique Cases of North Carolina and Rhode Island  

Navigating state-specific laws can be overwhelming. However, North Carolina and Rhode Island are unique cases that exemplify the contrasting approaches to employment laws in each state. 

North Carolina

North Carolina's policy on PTO is governed primarily by the North Carolina Wage and Hour Act (WHA), just like its approach towards the minimum wage of $7.25 per hour and overtime pay that exceeds 40 in a workweek. North Carolina doesn’t require the employee to offer any PTO, such as vacation or sick leave. 

However, the State empowers employers to have the freedom to decide. Once offered by the employer, these benefits should be provided to the employees, and any modifications in the PTO policies should be presented in an official document. 

However, it’s important to remember that benefits like pensions or health insurance are federally regulated, and North Carolina's Department of Labor doesn't get involved. 

Rhode Island 

Unlike North Carolina, Rhode Island takes a more proactive approach toward employee benefits. The Healthy and Safe Families and Workplaces Act requires employees with 18 employees or more to provide paid sales and sick leave that can accrue over time.

Moreover, the Rhode Island Parental and Family Medical Leave Act requires covered employers to provide up to 13 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave during any 24-month period for eligible employees to care for a new child or seriously ill family member. 

Both North Carolina and Rhode Island have contrasting approaches when it comes to PTO regulations. While North Carolina offers employers more flexibility in providing paid time off benefits, Rhode Island focuses more on ensuring employee well-being through mandated paid sick leave and unpaid family leave programs.

Understanding these variations can help you adhere to the state policies and ensure employee compliance and fairness. 

Company Policies vs. State Laws: Which Prevails?

Sometimes, companies' policies differ from state laws. But regardless of the differences, state laws always dominate company policies. 

State laws are enacted by elected representatives. Thus, these rules and regulations reflect the collective opinion of the people within a state. This ensures the protection of employee rights and fair play within workplaces.

On the contrary, company policies are internal regulations. They are created by the business specifically for its employees. While a company may offer additional benefits/rules, it cannot violate current state laws. 

Let's take an example of minimum wage. If a state requires the employed to pay a minimum wage of $10 per hour, the company cannot pay the employees below that threshold. Similarly, if a state law requires overtime pay for hours worked beyond 40 in a week.

In that case, company policy cannot prevent overtime pay. Moreover, the company could even offer to pay an extra overtime rate. 

In the case of PTO, while several state laws may not require paid time off, a company policy can offer employees a particular number of days for paid vacation every year. 

But it's important to remember that company policies must align with state laws. If a state law addresses a specific issue, such as PTO payout upon termination, employers must follow the law regardless of the company's policies. 

But what if the employees and employers operate from different states? 

This situation usually occurs when employees work from home. In that case, employees must follow the rules and regulations of their state. Employment-related laws like wage per-hour regulations, employee rights, unemployment compensation, and workers' compensation are all compensated based on the employee's regional law.

Particularly because working remotely is still a fairly new concept, it is worth working with a lawyer to ensure you are covering all your bases.

Specific Situations and Considerations for PTO

Here are a few specific situations where the laws or regulations around PTO may differ. Let’s review them all.

Do Companies Have to Pay Out Sick Time?

While most states do not require employers to pay out unused sick leave when an employee is terminated from their job, there are some notable exceptions for specific states.

California's paid sick leave law does not require employers to pay out accrued unused sick leave upon termination, resignation, retirement, or separation from employment.

New York also does not require payout of unused sick leave upon employment separation, however, it does allow employees to accrue sick time and carry over to the next year.

On the other hand, states with no laws regarding paid sick leaves leave it upon the employers to establish their sick leave policies. The company must decide whether the set time will be paid at termination. 

Use-It-Or-Lose-It Policies: Legal or Not?

Use-it-or-lose-it policies are all about the rules that mandate employees to utilize their accrued vacation or PTO before a specific deadline. Failure to do so can risk losing it entirely. 

Several states permit the use-it-or-lose-it policies, enabling employers to set up policies requiring employees to use their accrued vacation or PTO within a specified period or lose it.

However, even in states that allow these policies, there are several restrictions and regulations on how these policies should be implemented.

On the contrary, several states have laws prohibiting use-it-or-lose-it policies. These laws mandate that employers allow employees to accrue unused vacation or PTO time for use in the subsequent year. States, including New York, Montana, California, and Illinois, implement these laws.  

States with vague laws regarding use-it-or-lose-it policies may also allow employers to implement such policies. Still, they should ensure their policies comply with state labor laws and regulations.

Employees must thoroughly review their company's stance on vacation and PTO carry-over and usage to comprehend whether use-it-or-lose-it policies, their rights, and any relevant state laws apply to them.

Does My Company Have to Pay Me for Unused Vacation Time?

Whether or not a company must pay out unused vacation time upon termination of an employment contract depends on several factors, including state law, company policy separating employee names, employment separation, and employment separation contracts.

In states with laws mandating vacation payouts, such as California, Illinois, and others, employers must mostly pay out accrued but unused vacation time, which is considered wages, to employees upon termination. These laws define accrued vacation time and consider wages as earned wages that must be paid to employees upon their termination, regardless of the reason or cause.

On the other hand, states without laws requiring vacation payout allow employers to have the upper hand in determining their vacation payout policies. Some companies may have vacation pay policies that provide vacation payout upon termination, while others may not. 

Employees must review their company's policies and any applicable state laws or employment contracts to understand whether they are entitled to payment for unused vacation time upon termination and under what circumstances. 

Here are some common scenarios that might occur: 

Payout

Several states require employees to pay out accrued, unused PTO to their employees in case of termination or employee resignation. Usually, this payment is processed in the final salary of the employees. 

Forfeiture

Employees who work in states or companies that encourage use-it-or-lose-it policies can lose their unused paid time off if they haven't used it within a particular time frame. In these cases, employees may not be entitled to payment for unused PTO.

Carryover

Many companies offer employees the option to carry over unused PTO to the next year. This doesn't depend on whether the employees are quitting their jobs. Some situations allow employees to use their accrued PTO before their last work day. Plus, they can carry it over to their new employer if they have one.

Partial Payout

Some companies require employers to pay only a portion of the accrued PTO upon termination. This occurs when employees are terminated for a particular cause—e.g., violating a company's policy or if they haven't met the eligibility criteria to receive full PRO. 

PTO Management with Knit People

Paid Time Off (PTO) is a vital component of employee benefits. The PTO policy allows employees to take time off for personal reasons while receiving regular pay. PTO policies include vacation time, sick leave, personal days, bereavement leave, paid holidays, floating holidays, parental leave, etc. 

However, the rules and regulations that address PTO payout can vary from state to state. Both employers and employees need to get a comprehensive understanding to ensure compliance and fairness. 

This is where Knit People can help you out! 

Tailored to meet the needs of small businesses, Knit People offers PTO management that can effectively simplify the PTO payout and help you manage the payroll of employees. 

Using Knit People, your team can:

  • Do smart time-tracking.
  • Request and track custom leave time.
  • Make manual adjustments to time off easily.
  • Have self-service options that reduce review time by managers.

With Knit People, you’ll always stay on top of state laws and legal policies to ensure compliance. Start with the 30-day free trial today!

Get your team working with Knit!

Contact Us